.Collingwood's large 2023 off-season propose ex-Fremantle onward Lachie Schultz has actually come under fire, along with the premiers gazing down the really genuine case of giving away a top-10 pick.The Magpies depended their 2024 luck when they traded away choose 34 plus their future first-round selection in exchange for Schultz in the most recent exchange period.With a lot of the AFL world assuming the Magpies to require the leading 4 once again, this trade valued Schultz at about choose 8, according to the AFL Receipt Value Index - a high cost yet one they wanted to pay for, if they were actually giving up something like selection 16. Watch Hawthorn v Collingwood SAT 4:35 PM AEST|LIVE & unique to Fox Footy, offered on Kayo. New to Kayo? Begin your complimentary trial today > Round 19WHAT'S GAMING REALLY PRICED AT YOU? Prepare a down payment limit.But Collingwood presently sits 12th on the step ladder as well as, with poor form and a hard continuing to be draw, could realistically end up in the bottom six.As it stands they will hand Fremantle the No. 7 choice, along with the general trade then valuing Schultz as approximately pick 4, according to the AFL Allotment Worth Index.Current Lachie Schultz business detailsCOLLINGWOOD gets Lachie SchultzFREMANTLE receives Choose 7 (2024) and also Select 34 (2023 )Select 34 was actually on-traded to Richmond and then West Coast, utilized due to the Eagles on Clay HallCraig McRae, Elderly Person Coach of the Magpies talks with Lachie Schultz of the Magpies at area time in the course of the 2024 AFL Cycle 12 suit between the Collingwood Magpies and also the Adelaide Crows at The Melbourne Cricket Ground on May 31, 2024 in Melbourne, Australia. (Photograph through Dylan Burns/AFL Photos through Getty Images) Resource: Getty Images" The business that they made to receive Lachie Schultz in, which I supported at that time, I experienced this was actually gon na be a superb recruit," Kane Cornes claimed on Nine's Footy Classified." Yet you take a look at it 6 months down the monitor, you go, properly this has been a disaster truly. And also they allow Ginnivan go." Ginnivan's about to switch 22 at the end of the year, Schultz is actually gon na be actually 27, as well as Ginnivan is generating significantly greater influence in basically every stat ... he's been an even more impactful player." Cornes is actually not quite appropriate on the players' 2024 production, with Schultz in advance on the across-the-board AFL Gamer Scores metric as well as creating additional goals, handles and stress takes action per game.LACHIE SCHULTZ vs JACK GINNIVAN in 2024 (Standards) Fingertips: Schultz 11.3, Ginnivan 16Marks inside 50: Schultz 1.5, Ginnivan 1.3 Goals: Schultz 1.3, Ginnivan 1.1 Score aids: Schultz 0.5, Ginnivan 1.1 Score participations: Schultz 4.8, Ginnivan 5.5 Tackles: Schultz 3.87, Ginnivan 2.53 Stress acts: Schultz 18.1, Ginnivan 15.5 AFL Player Rankings: Schultz 6.85, Ginnivan 5.98 Nonetheless the effects of both are actually very much comparable, while the cost spent to acquire Schultz as well as return for Ginnivan are not.Ginnivan was traded to Hawthorn in a multi-pick swap, with Collingwood acquiring choice thirty three plus the Hawks' 2024 2nd and third-round selections, while the Hawks gained Ginnivan, select 39 and also the Magpies' 2024 2nd and also fourth-round picks.Given the Hawks were actually assumed to end up below the Magpies, the future selection swaps were recognized as a succeed for Collingwood, however they might have in fact devalued those collections making the business just about a full wash.It is absolutely nowhere near to the top-10 pick yield Fremantle is actually probably to receive for Schultz." What has taken place to our great video game!"|03:35" One of the most involving factor is you provided Pick 7 as it rests at the moment. That's what we've come to happen, and also they've received a hard draw plus all of that," Cornes said." So you've traded your future initially for a gamer who is essentially supplying what you had with another gamer, that you handed out for more or less nothing, and also you have actually also provided that terrific selection inside the best 10 as it sits - which they desperately require." The Magpies could anxiously make use of that collection along with an outdated checklist and also a shortage of talent obtained via the nationwide draft in recent years.While Chip Daicos is a celebrity, and the similarity Isaac Quaynor (choose 13) and also Beloved McCreery (decide on 44) were terrific pick-ups, Craig McRae's side has otherwise strained at the draft with probably only four smash hits in five years.From the 2021-23 allotments merely Harvey Harrison has actually participated in double-digit games, while 2018 and 2019 supplied absolutely nothing away from Quaynor.In the 2020 allotment, where the Pies had 4 picks in the best 30 as well as 6 in the top 44, simply McCreery and also the since-traded Ollie Henry are actually clear best-23 players.The choices of John Noble and Ash Johnson in the mid-season draft, plus pre-season supplemental pick-up Oleg Markov, have actually been important given the nationwide draft skips.